The Case For An Off Chain Internet w/ Evin McMullen | Built On Web3 Podcast #017
[sean_crowe]: welcome to another episode of built on
web three today we are so excited and
[sean_crowe]: so lucky to chat with the one
and only
[evin___disco]: m
[sean_crowe]: evan
[evin___disco]: g m everybody
[sean_crowe]: mc mullen
[evin___disco]: thank you
[sean_crowe]: the
[evin___disco]: so
[sean_crowe]: c
[evin___disco]: much for
[thomas_gorczynski]: oh
[sean_crowe]: o
[evin___disco]: having
[sean_crowe]: and
[evin___disco]: me
[sean_crowe]: founder of disco dot x
[evin___disco]: i
[sean_crowe]: z even welcome to the show
[evin___disco]: ah
[sean_crowe]: oh yeah
[evin___disco]: that is indeed correct
[sean_crowe]: as i was doing research i noticed
and you just mentioned you might be from
[sean_crowe]: northeast ohio
[evin___disco]: oh my
[sean_crowe]: is
[evin___disco]: gosh
[sean_crowe]: that correct
[evin___disco]: absolutely yes we would play hudson
[sean_crowe]: i grew
[evin___disco]: in
[sean_crowe]: up
[evin___disco]: sports
[sean_crowe]: in hudson
[evin___disco]: when i was a kid
[thomas_gorczynski]: m
[sean_crowe]: were you near there
[evin___disco]: i grew up i'm just east of
cleveland
[thomas_gorczynski]: oh
[evin___disco]: in a town called chesterland in giaga
[sean_crowe]: yeah
[evin___disco]: county
[sean_crowe]: where did you grow up
[evin___disco]: see
[sean_crowe]: okay
[evin___disco]: nerves are multi
[thomas_gorczynski]: oh
[sean_crowe]: vaguely
[evin___disco]: faceted
[sean_crowe]: familiar
[evin___disco]: too
[sean_crowe]: i think we did play in sports
amazing small world oh yes exactly
[evin___disco]: yeah
[thomas_gorczynski]: okay
[sean_crowe]: and and i assume
[evin___disco]: perfect
[sean_crowe]: you're
[evin___disco]: internet
[sean_crowe]: flying
[evin___disco]: weather
[sean_crowe]: out there
[evin___disco]: i
[sean_crowe]: for the
[evin___disco]: say
[sean_crowe]: holidays
[thomas_gorczynski]: yeah
[sean_crowe]: so i hear it's going to be
cold so well we'll have to bundle up
[thomas_gorczynski]: oh
[evin___disco]: oh
[sean_crowe]: that's awesome so i want to start
this off kind of talking about how we
[sean_crowe]: can better explain
[evin___disco]: m
[sean_crowe]: web three
[evin___disco]: m
[sean_crowe]: to people not in this space so
we're all going home for the holidays our
[sean_crowe]: parents will inevitably ask us what we're
doing what this podcast is about and i
[sean_crowe]: want to kind of get your take
on this so our thomas and is day
[sean_crowe]: job is we run
[evin___disco]: yes
[sean_crowe]: an agency
[evin___disco]: yeah
[sean_crowe]: of soft agency in last week i
held a web three one o one thing
[sean_crowe]: for our team and i challenged myself
not to use the word n f t
[sean_crowe]: decentralized or an
[evin___disco]: m
[sean_crowe]: these words to confuse everybody in explaining
what way three is and i want the
[sean_crowe]: crysticsinroute where i basically just said it's
about digital ownership right in the feedback i
[sean_crowe]: got was good but i think the
piece i missing is how to make web
[sean_crowe]: three big how to make that a
moment and so my question u is
[evin___disco]: yes
[sean_crowe]: is there anything you found yourself using
in explaining web three that kind of sparks
[sean_crowe]: that a
[evin___disco]: so
[sean_crowe]: moment that
[evin___disco]: when
[sean_crowe]: big
[evin___disco]: i
[sean_crowe]: idea
[evin___disco]: think about
[sean_crowe]: of
[evin___disco]: web three
[sean_crowe]: really getting people to
[evin___disco]: obviously
[sean_crowe]: grasp
[evin___disco]: all
[sean_crowe]: what
[evin___disco]: of
[sean_crowe]: web
[evin___disco]: us have
[sean_crowe]: three is
[evin___disco]: different
[sean_crowe]: how big it can
[evin___disco]: definitions
[sean_crowe]: be
[evin___disco]: but um at disco when we talk
about web three we think about the universe
[evin___disco]: locked with public ledgers and private keys
and so
[sean_crowe]: oh
[evin___disco]: from
[sean_crowe]: yeah
[evin___disco]: verbal perspective this means basically nothing
[sean_crowe]: no
[evin___disco]: to our friends and family so we
need to show them we know what are
[evin___disco]: the outcomes and experiences made possible with
this kind of infrastructure um and so one
[evin___disco]: of my favorite things to do is
invite people to tell me about the as
[evin___disco]: if content the books movies or television
shows that informed what they thought the future
[evin___disco]: would be like when they were kids
and so much of these memories is wound
[evin___disco]: up in automation n personalization in robot
robot side kicks and not having to fill
[evin___disco]: out forms and stay and lines in
order to enjoy personalized experiences being able to
[evin___disco]: move seamlessly from one space to another
and have those environments and vehicles and spaces
[evin___disco]: respond to you and so you know
i just go when we think about the
[evin___disco]: new term future we talk about throwing
a super fun party a disco disco at
[evin___disco]: the louvre in paris and inviting everybody
to come um where the only thing they
[evin___disco]: need to bring with them is their
disco data back back so that a them
[evin___disco]: to move sceamlessly through the doors that
they're building a ride share border screenings health
[evin___disco]: screenings security screenings airport screenings um you
being able to move sceamlessly through all of
[evin___disco]: space is to a hotel to the
door of the v i p room at
[evin___disco]: the event where you're enjoying a personalized
experience because our definition of the mediverse is
[evin___disco]: your ability to move freely from one
spa to another without the need to explicitly
[evin___disco]: state any of your preferences to enjoy
personalized experiences that are built around you without
[evin___disco]: first having to ask um and that's
also why we're called disco because we believe
[evin___disco]: you are the multi faceted center of
the party just just like this disco ball
[evin___disco]: and you should be able to reflect
your data and your identity to the world
[evin___disco]: however you decide you're a different person
when you show up um you know with
[evin___disco]: your family with your friends in professional
settings in public and private and your ability
[evin___disco]: to selectively decide how you want to
present yourself which part of
[sean_crowe]: oh
[evin___disco]: your if you want to reflect is
you know is very much a poor principle
[evin___disco]: of your individualism and so when we
talk about
[sean_crowe]: a
[evin___disco]: you know
[sean_crowe]: oh
[evin___disco]: the desire to remove friction to fill
out your four i'm just to wait in
[evin___disco]: four lines to you be able to
take your uber rating with you to to
[evin___disco]: a new ride chair to be able
to enjoy an under collateral ized loan based
[evin___disco]: on reputation you've built
[sean_crowe]: m
[evin___disco]: out of a financial system these kinds
of examples become much more tangible i think
[sean_crowe]: m
[sean_crowe]: yeah i love that so going on
before we get into how disco is helping
[sean_crowe]: all this possible going on that that
example of going to the love and going
[sean_crowe]: to this party how could i how
could experience become more personal if i can
[evin___disco]: so
[sean_crowe]: take
[evin___disco]: you can imagine
[sean_crowe]: my
[evin___disco]: that
[sean_crowe]: verified credentials
[evin___disco]: being able
[sean_crowe]: my
[evin___disco]: to line up your
[sean_crowe]: pieces
[evin___disco]: itinerary
[sean_crowe]: of my dada back
[evin___disco]: beforehand
[sean_crowe]: back with me
[evin___disco]: and have a bunch of pre set
preferences that you don't need to articulate such
[evin___disco]: as the time of rival of a
ride share to pick you up to go
[evin___disco]: to the airport being now spaced to
your preference of how early you like to
[evin___disco]: arrive the day's traffic in the anticipated
number of people at the
[sean_crowe]: m
[evin___disco]: airport or even free particular
[sean_crowe]: h
[evin___disco]: flight being able to anticipate
[sean_crowe]: m
[evin___disco]: the type of ride share what sort
of music the temperature the seating arrangement how
[evin___disco]: much luggage you're going to have in
addition to you know your language preferences and
[evin___disco]: your pronoun preferences so really granular sorts
of things like
[sean_crowe]: m
[evin___disco]: settings page for your experience of the
whole world can be articulated beforehand such that
[evin___disco]: when you interact with different services that
can
[sean_crowe]: yeah
[evin___disco]: be personalized there can be umyouknwcan you
[sean_crowe]: m
[evin___disco]: can remove some administrivia
[sean_crowe]: oh
[evin___disco]: you're able to have a much more
seamless way to access kinds of things especially
[evin___disco]: in tandem co ordinating one with another
because of course human co ordination
[sean_crowe]: oh
[evin___disco]: is what we're all about here anyway
[sean_crowe]: oh yeah yeah
[evin___disco]: oh
[sean_crowe]: oh yes so disco is helping all
this happen right and you're solving some really
[sean_crowe]: really important issues that two has not
been able to solve and i think what
[sean_crowe]: you guys are doing is going to
be foundational to web three in can you
[sean_crowe]: kind of lay the foundation here and
paint us a picture of the problems
[evin___disco]: so
[sean_crowe]: that were
[evin___disco]: right
[sean_crowe]: ing today
[evin___disco]: now
[sean_crowe]: in web two
[evin___disco]: when you
[sean_crowe]: that
[evin___disco]: use
[sean_crowe]: disco
[evin___disco]: an application
[sean_crowe]: is then addressing
[evin___disco]: web too when you
[sean_crowe]: to
[evin___disco]: visit
[sean_crowe]: help create
[evin___disco]: instagram
[sean_crowe]: this picture
[evin___disco]: or
[sean_crowe]: of the
[evin___disco]: google
[sean_crowe]: future
[evin___disco]: um or even use a collaboration tool
like notion or get hub when you're hanging
[evin___disco]: out inside of that applicato and you're
doing various activities clicking things creating data writing
[evin___disco]: documents collaborating with friends all of the
data that pertains to your interactions in that
[evin___disco]: space is so o sea within the
confines of that application or perhaps related application
[evin___disco]: system such as you know the google
universe the apple universe um and so the
[evin___disco]: data that you create that day exhaust
or trail of information that you leave as
[evin___disco]: a result of your actions is sort
of sihload to that appecosystem or to that
[evin___disco]: individual application itself and so you find
yourself interacting with new apes and having to
[evin___disco]: fill out on boarding forms just about
every time you interact not being able to
[evin___disco]: have usable forms sort of like auto
fill experiences universally across the board for and
[evin___disco]: certainly not for more than just being
able to fill out explicit form fields so
[evin___disco]: your preference for things like light or
dark mode or a primary language don't necessarily
[evin___disco]: travel you and so you continue to
have to update them certainly if you work
[evin___disco]: in the crypto space you may have
had to fill out some event bread forms
[evin___disco]: some party full forms some r s
v p forms to allow you to attend
[evin___disco]: various different events very rarely is it
easy
[thomas_gorczynski]: ah
[evin___disco]: to be able to re use your
information to populate to populate those kinds of
[evin___disco]: things but also it's it's challenging to
be able to capture
[thomas_gorczynski]: oh
[evin___disco]: proofs that you indeed were there and
to carry those with you over time
[thomas_gorczynski]: oh
[evin___disco]: in a way that's going to be
you know low cost simple less and uh
[evin___disco]: and independently
[thomas_gorczynski]: oh
[evin___disco]: verifiable so you have
[thomas_gorczynski]: yeah
[evin___disco]: a pretty good understanding that when i
carry this proof that is indeed written about
[evin___disco]: me
[thomas_gorczynski]: so does this go does disco introduce
any sort of centralization or does it actually
[thomas_gorczynski]: empower more of a decentralized like echos
um um i guess like how does this
[thomas_gorczynski]: go plug into everything
[evin___disco]: so that's a really great question because
it invites us to contemplate what do we
[evin___disco]: mean when we say decentralization do we
mean physically decentralized infrastructure that is bound to
[evin___disco]: a single netware do we mean the
portability of data and its ability to move
[evin___disco]: freely from one platform storage to another
so that we do not experience platform locking
[evin___disco]: do we mean decentralization and that no
um you know single party has the ability
[evin___disco]: to impact or influence it at scale
um and so there are a lot there's
[evin___disco]: a lot of nuance in this definition
when we think about the role of data
[evin___disco]: that's written a person or an organization
individual party even be an entity like a
[evin___disco]: dog or a car but we think
about the sovereignty especially of those now the
[evin___disco]: human beings sitting behind those keys when
we talk about self sovereignty it does we
[evin___disco]: mean an egosystem in which the subjective
data has the most control over the data
[evin___disco]: that describes it and so that doesn't
mean complete control and total control of course
[evin___disco]: that just means ore control than any
other party and so what we are implying
[evin___disco]: here is a logical centralization of control
around the data subject around the person that
[evin___disco]: it's written about but that can all
so repaired with a physical decentralization of the
[evin___disco]: places where that data is actually stored
so different kinds of data can be appropriate
[evin___disco]: to be stored in different sorts of
places based on the amount of availability we
[evin___disco]: need sort of mutability or efhemerality of
that data or need for it to persist
[evin___disco]: or to go away or change in
involve and so all of those different variables
[evin___disco]: can influence the best way store stash
that data especially now depending on how often
[evin___disco]: you're retrieving it using it validating it
and so it's really important for us to
[evin___disco]: ensure that no matter what we prioritize
the sovereignty and informed consent of individual users
[evin___disco]: so that they are able to understand
and interact with the work product that is
[evin___disco]: their data you know after all it
only this as a result of their actions
[evin___disco]: and the choices that they make um
interacting with these various difdifferent applications and so
[evin___disco]: we can also create much more business
efficient environment on the out side if but
[evin___disco]: he's not starting redundant copies of information
that all take up the same amount of
[evin___disco]: space and all need to be stashed
and stashed somewhere and you no reference on
[evin___disco]: non zero basis and so were able
to hopefully explore better g p r compliance
[evin___disco]: and not having to worry about things
like the physical storage and insurance and protection
[evin___disco]: of duplicate copies of data that otherwise
could very simply be provided with usable credential
[sean_crowe]: m
[sean_crowe]: from an ap
[evin___disco]: yeah
[sean_crowe]: development perspective just out of curiosity how
so how would that work with what you
[sean_crowe]: guys have built so if if i'm
building an ap and i don't want to
[sean_crowe]: just have a form
[evin___disco]: so
[sean_crowe]: there and i want
[evin___disco]: as
[sean_crowe]: to
[evin___disco]: a developer
[sean_crowe]: use some
[evin___disco]: you
[sean_crowe]: one's data
[evin___disco]: can
[sean_crowe]: pack
[evin___disco]: occupy
[sean_crowe]: and use their preferences
[evin___disco]: a couple o different
[sean_crowe]: how do
[evin___disco]: roles
[sean_crowe]: i access that
[evin___disco]: or your
[sean_crowe]: as a developer
[evin___disco]: application can occupy a couple o different
roles in the life cycle of a credential
[evin___disco]: or the life cycle of the data
that describes a person you can be the
[evin___disco]: kind of party that is issuing that
data that is handing over statements written about
[evin___disco]: that individual user organization that they can
and carry with them
[sean_crowe]: oh
[evin___disco]: to other spaces or you're a relying
party or a verifyer your application is looking
[evin___disco]: to rely upon data that comes to
the front door of your episode this is
[evin___disco]: the example that you just outlined so
for both of these partnerships we have to
[evin___disco]: think about you know what is the
interaction that they're really trying to achieve so
[evin___disco]: in terms of issuance it's about how
do i select the right credential schema how
[evin___disco]: do i
[sean_crowe]: oh
[evin___disco]: create the right form so it's still
be three compliant and resolvable and how do
[evin___disco]: i ensure that that's issued and signed
in a way that the keys that present
[evin___disco]: it that sign issue it or belong
to a party that has authority over the
[evin___disco]: contents it contains so that it can
be useful and then on the verifier side
[evin___disco]: we've got to ask who signed this
crit tell um is it valid or valid
[evin___disco]: for the purposes that i need so
is the cryptography intact is the signature sort
[evin___disco]: of resolvable as expected is the date
of idity in tact has it not expired
[evin___disco]: or not been revoked um so additionally
a little bit of nuance here is that
[evin___disco]: even if a credential has expired or
been revoked it can still be used for
[evin___disco]: certain purposes so you can imagine even
if your driver's license is expired it can
[evin___disco]: still be useful to prove that you
are over a certain age so we've got
[evin___disco]: a lot of flexibility in the way
we can interpret this data but a really
[evin___disco]: nice thing about the disco e goes
them is that we make
[sean_crowe]: m
[evin___disco]: these sorts of nuance questions pretty easy
to answer we have an a pi that
[evin___disco]: allows applications to validate credentials that user
presents a and call those credentials hat are
[evin___disco]: related to users given public address so
make it easy to access and then analyze
[evin___disco]: those credentials and ensure that they are
indeed the droits that you're looking for the
[evin___disco]: qualifications or trades you're seeking to unlock
access to an experience or to be able
[evin___disco]: to provide a given service and then
this sort of more wholistic view of what
[evin___disco]: the data is allows you to do
find on your end you know what are
[evin___disco]: the rules that we have in our
community and our app an our ecosystem how
[evin___disco]: is it that we make sense of
this data that's being presented and then on
[evin___disco]: the issuemant side and sort of like
credential management and resolution clients had resolution side
[evin___disco]: we're building out our s d k
we're also really excited to have a schema
[evin___disco]: builder capability that will allow anyone to
in vision a new kind of credential whatever
[evin___disco]: that might be whether that's a proof
a vives a proof that you came to
[evin___disco]: my dinner party
[sean_crowe]: m
[evin___disco]: a proof that
[sean_crowe]: cool
[evin___disco]: you know i vouch for you to
date one of my friends whatever those things
[evin___disco]: are you know probably more likely financial
kinds of contributions to doze but whatever those
[evin___disco]: are folks are going to be able
to define their own
[sean_crowe]: he
[evin___disco]: with a simplicity of creating a google
pole so not having to right code and
[evin___disco]: be careful about structure and sort of
spect compliance as we currently have to today
[sean_crowe]: yeah i
[sean_crowe]: okay that's interesting so will this be
like an open market place of schemes like
[sean_crowe]: does there have to be like be
consensus
[evin___disco]: so anyone
[sean_crowe]: of
[evin___disco]: can
[sean_crowe]: a
[evin___disco]: create
[sean_crowe]: of
[evin___disco]: as
[sean_crowe]: a
[evin___disco]: many
[sean_crowe]: shema
[evin___disco]: schemes
[sean_crowe]: or
[evin___disco]: as they
[sean_crowe]: can
[evin___disco]: would
[sean_crowe]: anyone
[evin___disco]: like to and that
[sean_crowe]: create
[evin___disco]: is the beauty of
[sean_crowe]: multiple
[evin___disco]: open standards
[sean_crowe]: schemes for the
[evin___disco]: however
[sean_crowe]: same thing
[evin___disco]: we can achieve some really awesome network
effects if we're able to coordinate different organizations
[sean_crowe]: oh
[evin___disco]: issuing resolving schemes in a shared understanding
and shared language so all the schemes don't
[evin___disco]: necessarily have to be the same but
there needs to be some shared understanding of
[evin___disco]: what they represent and the validity of
their issues so really
[sean_crowe]: yeah
[evin___disco]: fortunate activity that's happening right now is
that over at the world wide web consort
[evin___disco]: the w three c the good people
who run the internet they not only have
[evin___disco]: presented us with these textbooks for design
realized identifies and verifiable credentials but there are
[evin___disco]: also some really inspiring leaders in the
identity space who have kicked off working groups
[evin___disco]: to address just this need for global
repository of as similar to scheme a dot
[evin___disco]: or but explicitly focused on verifiable credentials
and even the sort of
[sean_crowe]: m
[evin___disco]: preferred or allowed lists of issuers or
signers that represent or govern a given a
[evin___disco]: given scheme so you can gen that
a group of universities is going to be
[evin___disco]: the appropriate party to be associated with
diploma credentials that pertain to their institutions
[thomas_gorczynski]: but then if the university like if
a different university wanted to create their own
[thomas_gorczynski]: scheme or like add on
[sean_crowe]: m
[thomas_gorczynski]: to it they totally could to
[sean_crowe]: oh
[thomas_gorczynski]: meanwhile utilizing like the
[sean_crowe]: yeah
[thomas_gorczynski]: standard scheme that was for those universities
right
[evin___disco]: so the nice thing about schemes is
that you can issue the same ones identical
[evin___disco]: sort of schemes and fill them out
in different ways than other institutions you can
[evin___disco]: evolve a mat that already exists and
based
[sean_crowe]: i
[evin___disco]: the creation of a new one
[sean_crowe]: ah
[evin___disco]: upon an existing structure and really the
choice of schema is important in so far
[evin___disco]: as it is real vent to the
parties that will rely upon that credential in
[evin___disco]: the future so ensuring that the folks
who want to be able to resolve and
[evin___disco]: rely upon the data that you're encompassing
in a given credential you know if you're
[evin___disco]: prioritizing that use ability that portability and
wanting to optimize for the number for the
[evin___disco]: most verifying party is possible then you're
probably more than likely going to choose a
[evin___disco]: scheme it is aligned with other institutions
already
[sean_crowe]: yep that makes sense so of taking
a step back from more of like a
[sean_crowe]: user side perspective can you kind of
walk us through what
[evin___disco]: for
[sean_crowe]: the
[evin___disco]: sure
[sean_crowe]: experience
[evin___disco]: so
[sean_crowe]: of
[evin___disco]: disco
[sean_crowe]: someone is
[evin___disco]: is
[sean_crowe]: interacting
[evin___disco]: bring
[sean_crowe]: with
[evin___disco]: your
[sean_crowe]: their
[evin___disco]: own keys
[sean_crowe]: data
[evin___disco]: experience
[sean_crowe]: back pack
[evin___disco]: right
[sean_crowe]: and
[evin___disco]: now
[sean_crowe]: even
[evin___disco]: although
[sean_crowe]: creating
[evin___disco]: we're looking forward
[sean_crowe]: their data
[evin___disco]: to
[sean_crowe]: back pack
[evin___disco]: inviting users into a coustodial data back
pack experience in the future we can talk
[evin___disco]: about that later but for now we
invite users to bring their evm compatible keys
[evin___disco]: to the disco web app and then
connect their will with one click as they
[evin___disco]: would normally web three tap on the
back end will generate a descent i sed
[evin___disco]: identify or data back pack for you
and then invite you to fill out your
[evin___disco]: profile one last time so choosing a
profile picture of brief vio creating a linkage
[evin___disco]: that you own that dependently verifiable between
your data back
[sean_crowe]: m
[evin___disco]: back and your twitter handle your dens
[sean_crowe]: m
[evin___disco]: record or website your discord
[sean_crowe]: m
[evin___disco]: handle and then you're up and running
being able to interact with a disco web
[evin___disco]: app feels a little bit like a
personal settings page and apple wallet all wrapped
[evin___disco]: into one so your data back pack
is a collection of credentials rectangular j pegs
[evin___disco]: that you self custody that allow you
to unlock different privileges and also you know
[evin___disco]: interact with with other users in a
social manner so you can send and receive
[evin___disco]: g m credentials which are kind of
like facebook style pokes and snaps with other
[evin___disco]: users snaps are similar to kudos they
allow you to recognize another another
[sean_crowe]: m
[evin___disco]: data
[sean_crowe]: hm
[evin___disco]: back pack owner
[sean_crowe]: yeah
[evin___disco]: for their unique contributions immaculate vibes et
cetera um and then we also have a
[evin___disco]: number of organizations that are issuing credentials
of membership in good standing to the folks
[evin___disco]: in their squads and so all of
those incoming credentials will show up for you
[evin___disco]: in your in box um just array
of different j pegs rectangular jigs that if
[evin___disco]: you pop them open you can expand
them and see the decentralized identifiers or data
[evin___disco]: back that addresses
[sean_crowe]: m
[evin___disco]: of the party that issued it the
party that received it that's you as well
[evin___disco]: as pop open the full j w
t token so being able to interrogate it
[evin___disco]: all the way down to the studs
if desire and then this inter face also
[evin___disco]: as i mentioned makes it easy to
be able to send credentials to other users
[evin___disco]: and the you can also write omen
about yourself so you can fill up your
[evin___disco]: data back pack with some statement that
you write about yourself so this includes those
[evin___disco]: preferences around ap experience like light or
dark mode language pronouns things like t shirt
[evin___disco]: size even zodiac sign so where we're
really looking forward to soon integrating some other
[evin___disco]: credential scheme as around achievement so things
like certificates of completion graduation and educational co
[evin___disco]: heart participation
[evin___disco]: oh
[sean_crowe]: so if i'm understanding this correctly then
there's a kind of the sub set of
[sean_crowe]: credentials that are self issued that are
information about myself that only i could decide
[sean_crowe]: on and then there's a set of
credenti as that are issued by other parties
[sean_crowe]: like university
[evin___disco]: exactly
[sean_crowe]: or
[evin___disco]: yeah and often will
[sean_crowe]: play
[evin___disco]: differentiate
[sean_crowe]: in a volley ball
[evin___disco]: those
[sean_crowe]: league
[evin___disco]: types
[sean_crowe]: and
[evin___disco]: of
[sean_crowe]: they
[evin___disco]: credentials
[sean_crowe]: say i did it
[evin___disco]: as self attested credentials being the ones
that
[sean_crowe]: yeah
[evin___disco]: only i can decide about myself that
i can say about myself and those
[thomas_gorczynski]: yeah
[evin___disco]: are largely preferences or sort of personal
settings for how you would like to experience
[evin___disco]: the metaverse
[thomas_gorczynski]: so i think this is a kind
of like
[evin___disco]: m
[thomas_gorczynski]: a neat segu into another topic because
jan and i did a deep dive on
[thomas_gorczynski]: disco and by the way it was
like amongst our favorite and we something really
[thomas_gorczynski]: interesting about this co is how you
have to give consent that you like
[evin___disco]: uh
[thomas_gorczynski]: these credentials this stuff
[evin___disco]: ah
[thomas_gorczynski]: that's in your data back back is
something that you accept to versus someone just
[thomas_gorczynski]: said age random stuff and span whether
that's like legal or illegal content so i
[thomas_gorczynski]: love like a quick overview of that
for our listeners but then my question specifically
[thomas_gorczynski]: is around what about the things um
that you did that might like maybe weren't
[thomas_gorczynski]: so good for example like a speeding
ticket or maybe you had like an accident
[thomas_gorczynski]: and you don't want that to show
up in your in your data back pack
[thomas_gorczynski]: for like insurance records but it is
something that happened so it's like i can
[thomas_gorczynski]: i can see like the positive things
but what about the negative things too
[evin___disco]: my
[thomas_gorczynski]: that might actually happen with that
[evin___disco]: great question so when we think about
you know how we deliberately curate in and
[evin___disco]: present information about ourselves in the real
world right now we have a pretty incredible
[evin___disco]: degree of control over how that happens
when we understand that it's happening but when
[evin___disco]: we interact with applications and services there's
this whole separate conversation happening behind our backs
[evin___disco]: above our heads where applications are are
exchanging data about us that we don't have
[evin___disco]: a lot of awareness about our ability
to to intervene in and so this is
[evin___disco]: a double edged sort there are great
benefits of this in terms of you know
[evin___disco]: automation the fact that we've gotten this
as a society in terms of being able
[evin___disco]: to anticipate the kinds of things you
want to order from macdonald's at four o'clock
[evin___disco]: in the morning on an app but
we also don't have the ability to enjoy
[evin___disco]: a lot of the value that comes
with creating and re using and securing the
[evin___disco]: data that describes us in you know
the way that we prefer to move through
[evin___disco]: the world so what's really interesting about
web three public ledgers essentialized networks like etherium
[evin___disco]: and bit coin is that the censorship
resistance and transparency they enable also necessarily requires
[evin___disco]: an absence of consent at the wallet
layer so in the evmecosystem i cannot reject
[evin___disco]: sort of using it out of the
key parer let's say from something like mad
[evin___disco]: mask i cannot reject any token idea
that another wallet user wants to map to
[evin___disco]: my public key if you know my
wallet address you know how to send something
[evin___disco]: to me and of course we could
create all kinds of elaborate permission structures around
[sean_crowe]: yeah
[evin___disco]: this you know smart contracts that intercept
tokens and and things like that um but
[evin___disco]: you know although that is also true
there is merit in observing the fact that
[evin___disco]: the default system as it exists exists
is one that does not involve consent when
[evin___disco]: accepting public assets being associated with your
address now there are ways that you can
[evin___disco]: dissociate unwanted assets you can pay again
fee to burn that asset but now we've
[evin___disco]: got to pay money to get rid
of things that we didn't want anyway sort
[evin___disco]: of like you know having to pay
a fee to have someone scrape an unwonted
[evin___disco]: bumper sticker off of your car but
[sean_crowe]: oh
[evin___disco]: but i think there is
[sean_crowe]: m
[evin___disco]: lot more flexibility and native natively well
suited um you know features to verifiable credentials
[evin___disco]: to describe lot of the data that
pertains to us as individuals as as human
[evin___disco]: beings and so we're able to manage
with a little bit more discretion um which
[evin___disco]: data assets we want to hang
[sean_crowe]: yeah
[evin___disco]: on and present and which we don't
whereas if someone's looking at our public address
[evin___disco]: on block chain it's really hard to
decide which of these assets
[sean_crowe]: oh
[evin___disco]: did thomas and john want which of
these assets were air dropped gift it sent
[evin___disco]: to them span to them that we're
unwanted so there's a lot of additional context
[evin___disco]: that you've got to provide around public
assets when it pertains to how they got
[evin___disco]: mapped to a given public key you
know additional the inability to curate means that
[evin___disco]: we put a lot of pressure on
the front ends of applications that display our
[evin___disco]: on chain activity so we've got to
hide each application separately a silo set of
[evin___disco]: unwanted assets now of course this is
another fund solution where verifiable credentials could come
[evin___disco]: in and you could mark the assets
[sean_crowe]: hm
[evin___disco]: with credentials that you don't want to
see
[sean_crowe]: eh
[evin___disco]: and to carry that form to a
but you know totally beside the point um
[evin___disco]: when we talk about negative reputation you
know i think that that's a really
[sean_crowe]: oh interesting
[evin___disco]: valuable characteristic for us to contemplate in
any identity system and i'm so excited for
[evin___disco]: the day when we arrive when that's
going to be you know of the utmost
[evin___disco]: importance up front like we are still
on party invitations you know where we're not
[evin___disco]: quite at like the cartoral state and
speeding tickets and for
[thomas_gorczynski]: yep
[evin___disco]: my part i'm very excited
[sean_crowe]: oh
[evin___disco]: to welcome many more users into the
web three ecosystem before
[sean_crowe]: yeah
[evin___disco]: we start appealing to them with the
desirable
[sean_crowe]: oh
[evin___disco]: new experience of decentralized back in for
speeding tickets but i would prefer to throw
[evin___disco]: parties first
[sean_crowe]: uh
[evin___disco]: well and also you know we're not
[sean_crowe]: well i'm
[evin___disco]: immediately
[sean_crowe]: glad you're here doing
[evin___disco]: eliminating
[sean_crowe]: that because yeah
[evin___disco]: the existence
[sean_crowe]: nobody would get in
[evin___disco]: of
[sean_crowe]: web
[evin___disco]: law
[sean_crowe]: three
[evin___disco]: enforcement
[sean_crowe]: if that was the case
[evin___disco]: like you know let's try to address
one at a time the daily experience is
[evin___disco]: in people's lives where we can remove
friction and add delight and value and there
[evin___disco]: are infinity
[sean_crowe]: oh
[evin___disco]: hypotheticals that we can you know concern
ourselves with when it comes to him much
[evin___disco]: higher gravity user data and we'll get
there we'll get there very soon but
[sean_crowe]: hm
[evin___disco]: we will not enjoy the privilege of
considering the consequences of our far reaching actions
[evin___disco]: around sensitive data until we first figure
out how to have fun in web three
[evin___disco]: in the metaphors and for those who
would like to first jump to systems of
[evin___disco]: punishment and negative reputation as we as
we take our very first steps in building
[evin___disco]: this new plane i invite us to
take a step back together and think about
[evin___disco]: how can we make the space a
little bit more welcoming at least for its
[evin___disco]: very start
[sean_crowe]: yeah yeah this i had a twit
here pulled up i think you retweated it
[sean_crowe]: and i think it was a quote
from you it was on clear but it
[sean_crowe]: was the permanence of our public chains
are unintentionally diminishing the freedom for disenfranchised commun
[sean_crowe]: it is by publicizing the very traits
used to discriminate against them and i feel
[sean_crowe]: like that's exactly what we're talking about
here where you know you could get sent
[sean_crowe]: these soul bound n f ts and
you have no choice in the matter and
[sean_crowe]: doxes basically and people know more about
you than you want them to know about
[sean_crowe]: you and
[evin___disco]: that is absolutely
[sean_crowe]: and
[evin___disco]: all me
[sean_crowe]: from the
[evin___disco]: i
[sean_crowe]: sounds
[evin___disco]: feel
[sean_crowe]: of
[evin___disco]: really
[sean_crowe]: it just
[evin___disco]: strongly
[sean_crowe]: go completely
[evin___disco]: about
[sean_crowe]: solves
[evin___disco]: this
[sean_crowe]: that
[evin___disco]: that
[sean_crowe]: by bringing these
[evin___disco]: you know
[sean_crowe]: credentials
[evin___disco]: often
[sean_crowe]: off chain
[evin___disco]: public data that pertains to individuals
[sean_crowe]: oh
[evin___disco]: is more harmful when we're talking about
marginalized communities and having trades exposed that can
[evin___disco]: be used to m yeah to disenfranchie
them to limit their options whether that's their
[evin___disco]: race their gender their soc economic status
their region their primary language their citizenship and
[evin___disco]: so if we want to create a
more equitable world a more level playing field
[evin___disco]: in web three perhaps may be for
our a first act we don't replicate the
[evin___disco]: systems of disenfranchisement that we know to
already exist
[sean_crowe]: m yeah m
[sean_crowe]: do you have any specific
[evin___disco]: yeah
[sean_crowe]: examples of that
[evin___disco]: so
[sean_crowe]: that you're
[evin___disco]: i think
[sean_crowe]: you're
[evin___disco]: about
[sean_crowe]: looking
[evin___disco]: a lot
[sean_crowe]: forward to
[evin___disco]: on
[sean_crowe]: the
[evin___disco]: many
[sean_crowe]: day that
[evin___disco]: time
[sean_crowe]: this comes
[evin___disco]: horizons
[sean_crowe]: to fruition that
[evin___disco]: but
[sean_crowe]: web three and disco
[evin___disco]: the
[sean_crowe]: could
[evin___disco]: first
[sean_crowe]: solve
[evin___disco]: that i'm particularly excited about is shortening
the time of on boarding into a community
[evin___disco]: organization right now when you join a
daw it's like your first day on the
[evin___disco]: internet you have to hang out in
the discord participate contribute introduce yourself to everybody
[evin___disco]: kind of farm that reputation
[sean_crowe]: oh
[evin___disco]: and there's lot of merit in
[sean_crowe]: ye
[evin___disco]: coming in hot to a community
[sean_crowe]: oh
[evin___disco]: and finding your nice and contributing but
once you make those contributions once you're core
[evin___disco]: part of a guild you're writing the
newsletter organizing events and hosts twitter spaces it's
[evin___disco]: really difficult to capture proofs of a
job well done when you do that work
[evin___disco]: and so very often if you want
to participate in another day perhaps take on
[evin___disco]: another role or even move to a
new organization when you show up to their
[evin___disco]: discord on day on it's like your
first day on the internet again and the
[evin___disco]: whole ground hog day repeats and so
being able to capture proofs of your work
[evin___disco]: and your contribution whether those are your
individual preferences and proticipation in roles or the
[evin___disco]: way that you've shown up for your
organization or community being able to bring that
[evin___disco]: with you and show it as a
proof of contribution a new jobs to other
[evin___disco]: daws to new organizations that proof of
accountability can be used in so many creative
[evin___disco]: ways by as also it's a high
assurance anticiple proxy that you're probably not a
[evin___disco]: if you're showing up to twitter spaces
weekly and you're a good contributor and you
[evin___disco]: always bring pizza or whatever and so
so you know i'm really looking forward to
[evin___disco]: defining
[sean_crowe]: uh
[evin___disco]: with great granularity
[sean_crowe]: h
[evin___disco]: the different kinds of contribution that organizations
are excited to keep track of and allowing
[evin___disco]: individual contributors to take custody of those
kinds of proofs so that we can lower
[evin___disco]: the switching cost of moving from one
space and community another and web three and
[evin___disco]: start to see the kind of portability
that we've always been promised
[sean_crowe]: yet we we interviewed george from common
wealth that you introduced us to and it
[sean_crowe]: was an awesome conversation about dows and
dow tooling what are some and i think
[sean_crowe]: you guys are working with boys club
on like bata here so what are some
[evin___disco]: so
[sean_crowe]: credentials
[evin___disco]: we are so
[sean_crowe]: that
[evin___disco]: proud
[sean_crowe]: you're
[evin___disco]: and
[sean_crowe]: starting
[evin___disco]: excited
[sean_crowe]: the
[evin___disco]: to
[sean_crowe]: c
[evin___disco]: be working
[sean_crowe]: being
[evin___disco]: with boys
[sean_crowe]: issued
[evin___disco]: club and
[sean_crowe]: within
[evin___disco]: the very
[sean_crowe]: a
[evin___disco]: first
[sean_crowe]: down
[evin___disco]: credential
[sean_crowe]: for work
[evin___disco]: that they
[sean_crowe]: people
[evin___disco]: kicked off with
[sean_crowe]: that
[evin___disco]: is
[sean_crowe]: are
[evin___disco]: actually
[sean_crowe]: doing within
[evin___disco]: the most
[sean_crowe]: a do
[evin___disco]: popular one and what we see is
sort of the anchor credential not only in
[evin___disco]: our growth strategy but also in the
strategy of so many com unities so this
[evin___disco]: initial membership credential attests to an individual's
membership and good standing of that organization so
[evin___disco]: this proof is private by default can
be revoked or set to expire and it
[evin___disco]: is legible to or can be resolved
by the signature can be checked by more
[evin___disco]: than a hundred and fifty different kinds
of keys so etherium keys but coin keys
[evin___disco]: keys that are derived from p g
p email a kind different stuff so it's
[evin___disco]: very universally accessible information should the holder
decide that they want to share it um
[evin___disco]: this credential can be used to access
google collaboration tools like google poles or slides
[evin___disco]: or documents that kind of thing um
get hub repositories chat channels on telegram and
[evin___disco]: discord as well as role titles discounts
and access to exclusive merchandise on shopifi as
[evin___disco]: well as access to privileged on chain
logic so gated n f t minting appropriate
[evin___disco]: only for that membership credential holder are
accessible only for that membership credential holder as
[evin___disco]: well as we're starting to experiment with
permission to defy pools so how might we
[evin___disco]: have a defy pool where you can
only deposit or interact with that smart contract
[evin___disco]: if you have certain credentials off chain
so being able to have a go little
[evin___disco]: file just to chase on blob that
you can carry around and interact in so
[evin___disco]: many different spaces oh and i almost
forgot you can also you present that credential
[evin___disco]: for verification to access physical spaces so
for en parties even you know secure
[sean_crowe]: oh
[evin___disco]: physical locations where you want to keep
track of who's in that space being able
[evin___disco]: to have individual asset that has virtually
no marginal cost to create
[thomas_gorczynski]: a
[evin___disco]: and so universally valuable across
[thomas_gorczynski]: i yeah
[evin___disco]: so many different tools and planes i'm
just really excited to build out even more
[thomas_gorczynski]: ye
[evin___disco]: capabilities
[thomas_gorczynski]: my
[evin___disco]: as these communities grow and see migrations
to have that same
[thomas_gorczynski]: m
[evin___disco]: sort of point of access or combination
of access controls throughout their ecosystem so as
[evin___disco]: we add more roles and more types
of credentials pertaining to their contributions and participation
[evin___disco]: then we'll be able to have even
more nuance access control to all these different
[evin___disco]: spaces
[thomas_gorczynski]: i think it's amazing and how like
literally an infinite amount of ways that this
[thomas_gorczynski]: co can be used across like daws
to businesses
[evin___disco]: oh
[thomas_gorczynski]: to governments and so forth personal
[evin___disco]: as
[thomas_gorczynski]: preferences where do you think you're going
to be are you going to pick a
[thomas_gorczynski]: particular focus like daws because that does
seem like it's such a huge potential of
[thomas_gorczynski]: the future the other question i had
was what's the business model behind disco like
[thomas_gorczynski]: do you have any benefit to working
with one type of organization or a kind
[thomas_gorczynski]: of area than another or and how
do you make money
[evin___disco]: so to address your second question first
we are currently experimenting with how we can
[evin___disco]: contribute value to the application egosystem as
well as are our end users so by
[evin___disco]: better understanding how much risk we are
removing from these application how much frustration and
[evin___disco]: time complexity and drop off we're then
going to determine which so the flow we
[evin___disco]: think have the most value at the
most value and represent services that we can
[evin___disco]: charge for so my conjecture is that
relying parties applications that verify data that's bought
[evin___disco]: to there door that they otherwise would
have to request and store will will participate
[evin___disco]: in a tired subscription structure will always
have a free ter for our de gens
[evin___disco]: and our builders that definitely see
[thomas_gorczynski]: h
[evin___disco]: an opportunity to have an a p
i call
[thomas_gorczynski]: m
[evin___disco]: based business
[thomas_gorczynski]: yeah
[evin___disco]: here also in the future we're really
excited about better enabling ego system of discoverability
[thomas_gorczynski]: oh
[evin___disco]: having the disco tech or adapt store
essentially of different places where you can discover
[evin___disco]: experiences that will be more personalized based
on the credentials that you've just obtained or
[evin___disco]: interacted with in your data back pack
so being able to bridge the gap of
[evin___disco]: finding places to go hang out in
web three and things to do with your
[evin___disco]: keys that are going to be personalized
and interesting but not necessarily in a way
[evin___disco]: that relies only upon funding your wallet
um m and then you know when we
[evin___disco]: think about sort of how we how
we interact with this ego system all together
[evin___disco]: as users and as you know issuing
and relying parties we we really think about
[evin___disco]: what is that wholes journey of the
life cycle of a credential how can we
[evin___disco]: insure that we're bringing the maximum value
to the needs of the applications on both
[evin___disco]: sides while respecting the informed cans privacy
and participation of the subject of data the
[evin___disco]: human beings moving in between all of
these co ordination tools
[sean_crowe]: i love it i don't know what
thomas said that made me think of this
[sean_crowe]: question but sorry to go a little
more negative here but i was just thinking
[sean_crowe]: about the security of that back packs
and kind of how disco is involved in
[sean_crowe]: that i guess from a decentralization question
as well but like if for example you
[sean_crowe]: know how like f b i
[evin___disco]: oh
[sean_crowe]: goes to apple and they say give
me this data and apple says no and
[sean_crowe]: then everyone's matt at apple if the
f b i came to disco and said
[sean_crowe]: give
[evin___disco]: so
[sean_crowe]: me this person's private
[evin___disco]: your data
[sean_crowe]: credential
[evin___disco]: with disco
[sean_crowe]: is that even
[evin___disco]: as
[sean_crowe]: possible
[evin___disco]: it exists right
[sean_crowe]: for
[evin___disco]: now
[sean_crowe]: you guys
[evin___disco]: is incrypted
[sean_crowe]: to be forced
[evin___disco]: against your
[sean_crowe]: to
[evin___disco]: keys
[sean_crowe]: do that
[evin___disco]: by default and stored on the ceramic
network and so you and as the subject
[evin___disco]: of that data the owner and controller
of it as well as the owner and
[evin___disco]: control of the private key that overseas
its incription disco has no ability to intervene
[evin___disco]: between you and your data we could
receive that request and you know politely ask
[evin___disco]: you or let you know
[sean_crowe]: h
[evin___disco]: that it's been made but we have
no ability to seize and de crypt your
[evin___disco]: data
[sean_crowe]: yes
[evin___disco]: and share it with other parties
[sean_crowe]: oh
[evin___disco]: oh
[sean_crowe]: love it and are there any like
what is the biggest security risk then like
[sean_crowe]: what
[evin___disco]: so
[sean_crowe]: what are hackers going to try to
poke their holes into here
[evin___disco]: we eat
[sean_crowe]: can
[evin___disco]: with
[sean_crowe]: someone
[evin___disco]: our eyes
[sean_crowe]: spoof
[evin___disco]: first
[sean_crowe]: my identity
[evin___disco]: of course
[sean_crowe]: and
[evin___disco]: and
[sean_crowe]: spoof
[evin___disco]: so
[sean_crowe]: my credentials
[evin___disco]: whatever we see has a pretty significant
bearing on the information that we believe to
[evin___disco]: be true so as with all social
fishing and based misleading you know journeys intended
[evin___disco]: to trick us we do have some
amount of risk because of course we're consuming
[evin___disco]: this information through our eyeballs now there
are all kinds of trust cues that we're
[evin___disco]: really excited about introducing and rolling the
coming months that will help to alleviate some
[evin___disco]: of the concerns and allow
[sean_crowe]: hm
[evin___disco]: for an individual to interrogate an interaction
a little bit further than they can traditionally
[evin___disco]: so that they can feel confidence you
know what the choices they're making inside of
[evin___disco]: the app but i think we again
hit a bottle neck when we talk about
[evin___disco]: security around private key management and so
we're particularly excited about exploring some of the
[sean_crowe]: m
[evin___disco]: unique properties of did documents documents are
like the decentralized link tray or set of
[evin___disco]: directions or service and points for how
to interact with the decentralized identify or data
[evin___disco]: back back in our world and one
of those capabilities for some decentralized identify our
[evin___disco]: methods is the ability to rotate keys
so key rotation means that we can start
[evin___disco]: off with a custodia or semi custodial
experience we can rotate the keys that sit
[evin___disco]: behind public identify our
[sean_crowe]: m
[evin___disco]: and we can allow that individual organization
to ride off into the sunset as an
[evin___disco]: independent self custodial bank less entity umoukwowning
and controlling their data back pack and their
[evin___disco]: assets so for that gentle on boarding
where we don't necessarily need to start off
[evin___disco]: with private key management but we can
work up to it that does introduce a
[evin___disco]: lot of potential concern is as we
an even larger market
[sean_crowe]: m
[sean_crowe]: got to so i want to take
the last like ten or three minutes here
[sean_crowe]: really to talk about use cases and
try to paint a picture of what this
[sean_crowe]: world could look like with disco back
backs everywhere so what do you think the
[sean_crowe]: first experience
[evin___disco]: so
[sean_crowe]: someone
[evin___disco]: if your
[sean_crowe]: like
[evin___disco]: parents
[sean_crowe]: our parents will
[evin___disco]: are
[sean_crowe]: have
[evin___disco]: our
[sean_crowe]: using the verified
[evin___disco]: up
[sean_crowe]: verifiable
[evin___disco]: and running with their
[sean_crowe]: credentials
[evin___disco]: own private keys it's likely that the
first credential they'll receive is a membership credential
[evin___disco]: even outside of that as we start
to
[sean_crowe]: they're
[evin___disco]: welcome
[sean_crowe]: not
[evin___disco]: more and more users with you know
ing levels of familiarity with the underlying
[sean_crowe]: oh
[evin___disco]: technology and sort of independent self custody
[sean_crowe]: hm
[evin___disco]: i think that membership credentials of one
form or another are highly likely to be
[evin___disco]: the first that they interact with so
whether those are credentials of employment that attest
[evin___disco]: to the fact that they work somewhere
[thomas_gorczynski]: yeah
[evin___disco]: whether those are credentials of membership in
a physical club
[thomas_gorczynski]: yeah
[evin___disco]: or a group or organization credentials as
the jumping off
[thomas_gorczynski]: ah
[evin___disco]: point of access across environments
[thomas_gorczynski]: yeah
[evin___disco]: to different groups and communities i think
will continue to be a really strong first
[evin___disco]: experience
[thomas_gorczynski]: um from a use case of like
developers utilizing disco and i was thinking about
[thomas_gorczynski]: the business model to which i'm a
fan of i like that on like the
[thomas_gorczynski]: call basis um will the business model
well you have a very fluid and direct
[thomas_gorczynski]: relationship to developers such that like we
don't need to go through the like if
[thomas_gorczynski]: i if you wanted to create a
financial app today and you need to use
[thomas_gorczynski]: plat for example to you know hook
up the bank accounts and all this other
[thomas_gorczynski]: stuff it's a process to get that
is it going to be way faster with
[thomas_gorczynski]: disco and kind of like an automatic
like per usage kind of like debit almost
[thomas_gorczynski]: to the developer for just like each
micro transaction for each a p i call
[thomas_gorczynski]: that
[evin___disco]: yeah
[thomas_gorczynski]: such that you eliminate
[evin___disco]: oh
[thomas_gorczynski]: all the kind of headache with getting
set up just like you're trying to make
[thomas_gorczynski]: it easier for users to use this
code to on board to no forms and
[thomas_gorczynski]: stuff
[evin___disco]: so we actually think a lot about
and the feedback that we've gotten so far
[evin___disco]: has actually looked at these sort of
micro transaction based interactions is perhaps more cumbersome
[evin___disco]: and especially for you know for enterprise
applications that are you know thinking about their
[evin___disco]: their own sort of financial relationship with
their vendors and parties they rely upon and
[evin___disco]: so we're loring more of a tired
rate limited subscription model where we will have
[evin___disco]: options for free participation as well as
virtually unlit i uncapped credential factory or verify
[evin___disco]: factory for those parties that are interacting
at scale so our objective and of course
[evin___disco]: will be really flexible with these models
but always you know learning and experimenting but
[evin___disco]: our objective is to remove as
[sean_crowe]: oh
[evin___disco]: much friction as possible from the
[sean_crowe]: yeah
[evin___disco]: experience of our builders as well as
the experience of you know those rending that
[evin___disco]: the business teams associated with their apse
and services
[evin___disco]: ah
[sean_crowe]: so i'm definitely a hundred per cent
discopilled and i'm very bullish on this future
[sean_crowe]: but i'm curious are you seeing
[evin___disco]: oh
[sean_crowe]: any web two companies start to adopt
verify credentials because i'm just thinking of maybe
[sean_crowe]: like spotify for example in in this
world where they they can give me a
[sean_crowe]: credential or an n f t or
anything that says i am in the top
[sean_crowe]: point zero one percent of listeners of
taylor's left and i can take that to
[sean_crowe]: the concert and get unique experiences what's
in it for spotify to issue me very
[sean_crowe]: valuable credentials with
[evin___disco]: so
[sean_crowe]: an open standard
[evin___disco]: i think
[sean_crowe]: rather than just keeping
[evin___disco]: one
[sean_crowe]: that for themselves
[evin___disco]: really exciting
[sean_crowe]: and selling my data
[evin___disco]: part of the future that we're building
is that we can enable apt to consider
[evin___disco]: a two way data market place where
they are creating a known brand around the
[evin___disco]: data they hand over to users so
if you open your data back pack
[evin___disco]: sorry guys um so if you open
your data back pack and you're able to
[evin___disco]: leverage your spotified listening credential to prove
[sean_crowe]: yeah
[evin___disco]: your membership in the intailorslift fandom you're
able to carry that with you to ticketing
[evin___disco]: platforms to get preferred access to tickets
to dating platforms to find people to go
[evin___disco]: out with who will come to the
concert with you to commerce retail platforms that
[evin___disco]: will curate you know look similar to
hers or esthetic similar to the ones that
[evin___disco]: that taylor curates herself on um you
know whether it's tumilar interest or whatever and
[evin___disco]: so b able to easily address the
discoverability problem across planes and choose those experiences
[evin___disco]: best suited to
[sean_crowe]: yeah
[evin___disco]: what you're feeling at the time helps
to remove a lot of friction in in
[evin___disco]: that process and get you more quickly
to the adventure that you started off seeking
[evin___disco]: in the first place
[sean_crowe]: got it so and the first part
you said i figure how you phrased it
[sean_crowe]: but basically it's a branding opportunity for
spotifye because this this is a spotify credential
[sean_crowe]: that i'm taking do all of these
places and this is more
[evin___disco]: exactly
[sean_crowe]: touch
[evin___disco]: it's
[sean_crowe]: points
[evin___disco]: sort of
[sean_crowe]: with that
[evin___disco]: a
[sean_crowe]: brand
[evin___disco]: net new
[sean_crowe]: if they can create
[evin___disco]: form
[sean_crowe]: that schema
[evin___disco]: of value
[sean_crowe]: and really brand it
[evin___disco]: so
[sean_crowe]: for themselves
[evin___disco]: the more relevant pieces of information about
myself or you know tools or passes that
[evin___disco]: i collect
[sean_crowe]: h
[evin___disco]: from
[sean_crowe]: m
[evin___disco]: the spotify ecosystem then when i go
off into the big bag bad met verse
[evin___disco]: how much of my back pack is
owned by spotifyin
[sean_crowe]: okay
[evin___disco]: how much retail in the daily set
of tools and capabilities that i carry with
[evin___disco]: me is related to the experiences that
i have in that app and so for
[evin___disco]: some people you know like me i
love music and so muse represents a really
[evin___disco]: big portion of my life and so
[sean_crowe]: m
[evin___disco]: being able to accrue my experiences across
twitter spaces and concerts album listening parties and
[evin___disco]: pre saving songs on streaming platforms listening
across streaming platform sharing content with my friends
[evin___disco]: you know all these different activities right
now aren't necessarily following me to provide a
[evin___disco]: complete
[sean_crowe]: oh
[evin___disco]: picture of my fantom but even as
an individual
[sean_crowe]: a
[evin___disco]: as we know a spot if i
wrapped it's pretty awesome to be able to
[evin___disco]: behold the totality of your activity around
a specific subject or group organization or brand
[sean_crowe]: so to talk about just a slightly
different use case
[evin___disco]: oh
[sean_crowe]: for for us for content creators for
podcastersoutubers we were playing with this idea of
[sean_crowe]: issuing kind of a po app for
guests right what is the case to do
[sean_crowe]: this
[evin___disco]: so
[sean_crowe]: v verifiable
[evin___disco]: there are
[sean_crowe]: credentials
[evin___disco]: a lot of different ways that we
can
[sean_crowe]: not do this with an
[evin___disco]: recognize
[sean_crowe]: n f t
[evin___disco]: the contributions
[sean_crowe]: oh
[evin___disco]: and participation of different people in our
spaces i think the verifiable credentials are uniquely
[evin___disco]: well suited here because as much as
i love poets i love to you know
[evin___disco]: collect them they are kind of like
stickers in that they don't say a lot
[evin___disco]: about the person who holds them and
so if i come into custody
[sean_crowe]: oh
[evin___disco]: of a po ap that doesn't necessarily
[sean_crowe]: yeah
[evin___disco]: me that i you know am that
that it is representative of my experience so
[evin___disco]: if i have a pop that says
that i was a guest on the show
[evin___disco]: that doesn't necessarily mean i was a
guest on the show that just means that
[evin___disco]: a given toke i d has been
mapped to my public key and that token
[evin___disco]: i d points to r i with
j peg says that i was pro participant
[evin___disco]: on a given show so it's sort
of a proof of acquisition if you were
[evin___disco]: it comes to personal experiences
[sean_crowe]: yeh
[evin___disco]: and especially
[sean_crowe]: yeah
[evin___disco]: for something like participating on a show
where it's very explicit there is
[sean_crowe]: hm
[evin___disco]: a known
[sean_crowe]: yeah
[evin___disco]: show you are a non individual that's
the kind of proof that you're going to
[evin___disco]: want to be really proud of carry
with you and other parties might rely upon
[evin___disco]: such as you know future podcasts that
want to see you know actually been on
[evin___disco]: a podcast before and having this proof
might be relevant to them so the consequence
[evin___disco]: of the data i think makes it
a little more important which primitive you use
[evin___disco]: i think pops are super awesome and
fun and wonderful but they're also kind of
[evin___disco]: limited to the vmecosystem so if you
want to be able to surface this data
[evin___disco]: outside of the ecosystem or in a
web tube context in a little bit more
[evin___disco]: friendly manner this might be a good
good primitive for you to look into so
[evin___disco]: we would love to help you guys
set up verifiable credentials for your guests would
[evin___disco]: be happy to put that together we
actually already have a guest speaker credential so
[evin___disco]: it's just a matter of you stick
in your sticking your logo on it and
[evin___disco]: we can get those issues right away
[sean_crowe]: yeah
[thomas_gorczynski]: oh
[sean_crowe]: cool yeah
[evin___disco]: yeah
[sean_crowe]: let's do that that'll be really cool
[evin___disco]: so we're
[sean_crowe]: i
[evin___disco]: really
[sean_crowe]: imagine
[evin___disco]: excited
[sean_crowe]: you have
[evin___disco]: to not
[sean_crowe]: hundreds
[evin___disco]: only have those guest
[sean_crowe]: of
[evin___disco]: speaker
[sean_crowe]: guest speaker
[evin___disco]: credentials
[sean_crowe]: credentials
[evin___disco]: but also
[sean_crowe]: in your back
[evin___disco]: to
[sean_crowe]: back
[evin___disco]: allow
[sean_crowe]: at this
[evin___disco]: people
[sean_crowe]: point
[evin___disco]: to take them to different spaces so
when you apply for
[thomas_gorczynski]: oh
[sean_crowe]: yeah
[evin___disco]: a speaking engagement being able to surface
all of those credentials
[sean_crowe]: oh
[evin___disco]: or for example if you're
[thomas_gorczynski]: a
[sean_crowe]: yeah
[evin___disco]: teaching a course or leading a workshop
being able to share those credentials of experience
[thomas_gorczynski]: m
[evin___disco]: with with other folks
[thomas_gorczynski]: a
[evin___disco]: who are in your community could be
really relevant oh
[thomas_gorczynski]: yeah i wanted to pick your brain
[evin___disco]: m
[thomas_gorczynski]: and just see like how
[sean_crowe]: yep
[thomas_gorczynski]: crazy
[evin___disco]: yeah
[thomas_gorczynski]: this code can get into the future
or like how how like fun let's
[evin___disco]: m
[thomas_gorczynski]: see that way um so
[evin___disco]: oh
[thomas_gorczynski]: level one is universe like you complete
a course you get
[evin___disco]: my
[thomas_gorczynski]: you add to your back back that
like hey i completed
[evin___disco]: m
[thomas_gorczynski]: this you know of course
[evin___disco]: yes
[thomas_gorczynski]: i have this capability level a kind
of complexity is the whole do situation where
[thomas_gorczynski]: you contribute to a dot you can
go to another one and now you have
[thomas_gorczynski]: this proof that you've done this work
what are like what's three or four or
[thomas_gorczynski]: five like something that isn't applicable yet
in today's kind of world and state of
[thomas_gorczynski]: web three but you can force into
the future that's just kind mind blowing
[evin___disco]: so a fun example that a lot
of friends like to talk about when we
[evin___disco]: think about discoverability is disco as the
basis for a dating ap so you know
[evin___disco]: at the end of the day being
able to identify a sub set of your
[evin___disco]: data and the compatibility or fitness or
similarity of that data to someone else's able
[evin___disco]: to compare the same part of differen
data back facts um in a trust minimized
[evin___disco]: way without a centralized authority you know
taking advantage of that data and reselling it
[evin___disco]: et cetera m that's got the basis
for discoverability of human beings being able to
[evin___disco]: find one another and so that also
invites us to explore things like secure computation
[evin___disco]: over that data in an incrypted form
that also invites us to contemplate how do
[evin___disco]: we even define these parts an is
what does it mean for me to hold
[evin___disco]: on to copies of my references and
to allow those for first secure computation to
[evin___disco]: find other people know whether that's finding
friends to go skiing finding someone go out
[evin___disco]: with on saturday night or finding copanalists
for an event there are a lot of
[evin___disco]: different ways that we can imagine human
to human discoverability can provide a lot of
[evin___disco]: new lot of new openings or open
a lot of new doors rather for us
[evin___disco]: in this community
[evin___disco]: hm
[evin___disco]: oh
[sean_crowe]: so last question us because that popped
up there when you said that do so
[sean_crowe]: like as an apt developer if i
utilized the
[evin___disco]: so
[sean_crowe]: verifiable
[evin___disco]: right
[sean_crowe]: grentials
[evin___disco]: now we're
[sean_crowe]: from the
[evin___disco]: playing
[sean_crowe]: data back
[evin___disco]: with
[sean_crowe]: pack
[evin___disco]: the spectrum
[sean_crowe]: do i have visibility
[evin___disco]: of
[sean_crowe]: into
[evin___disco]: privacy
[sean_crowe]: that specific
[evin___disco]: and publicity
[sean_crowe]: data
[evin___disco]: that
[sean_crowe]: or
[evin___disco]: we
[sean_crowe]: is
[evin___disco]: can
[sean_crowe]: it
[evin___disco]: achieve
[sean_crowe]: i he
[evin___disco]: between
[sean_crowe]: skated
[evin___disco]: data that's incrypted and now only to
your keys and data that's public for everyone
[evin___disco]: on earth in space with an internet
connection on a public
[sean_crowe]: hm
[evin___disco]: ledger so some of the ways that
we can explore that includes decrypting data only
[evin___disco]: at the applayer for the end user
so there are a variety of differe
[sean_crowe]: m
[evin___disco]: ways also that we can compute upon
data and learn something about it without revealing
[evin___disco]: its plain text
[sean_crowe]: m
[evin___disco]: and
[sean_crowe]: m
[evin___disco]: so that sort of gets a little
bit more into the math of magic of
[evin___disco]: cryptography and so exactly yes it's just
sprinkle some zqs on it that's like the
[evin___disco]: vibe this week and so so sort
of that
[sean_crowe]: some
[evin___disco]: whole
[sean_crowe]: zqs
[evin___disco]: like area of the universe is what
allows us
[sean_crowe]: yeah
[evin___disco]: to examine more use our privacy preservation
while still enjoying the same level of data
[evin___disco]: availability and persistence that we would enjoy
from otherwise clearly accessible data in a local
[evin___disco]: data base
[sean_crowe]: oh
[evin___disco]: absolutely
[sean_crowe]: ah
[evin___disco]: any
[sean_crowe]: love
[evin___disco]: time
[sean_crowe]: it
[evin___disco]: we'll ee
[sean_crowe]: well
[evin___disco]: you guys in the
[sean_crowe]: evan
[evin___disco]: mediverse
[sean_crowe]: this was a blast we learned so
much thank you so much for being on
[sean_crowe]: the show
[sean_crowe]: sounds good give me one second here
and